Proof: A True Crime Podcast
Hosted by Susan Simpson
A serialized investigative podcast that dedicates each season to a single case of potential wrongful conviction.
This is a long-form, serialized true crime podcast where each season is a deep-dive investigation into a single potential wrongful conviction case. The show combines narrative storytelling in its main episodes with 'Sidebar' episodes that feature interviews with exonerees, legal experts, and reflections from the hosts. It functions as active investigative journalism, with the hosts uncovering new evidence and documents during their reporting.
“Proof's structure is its key differentiator: season-long narratives are supplemented by 'Sidebar' episodes that provide crucial context and humanize the issues through direct interviews with exonerees. Unlike many true crime shows, its investigations have directly contributed to the exoneration of wrongfully convicted individuals, demonstrating a real-world impact.”
Who hosts this show
Proof is a serialized investigation into cases of potential wrongful conviction. Hosted by attorney Susan Simpson of the Undisclosed Podcast and TV producer Jacinda Davis of Evil Lives Here, Proof unravels the tangled demands of the legal system and police practices to find the truth. The hosts' work on the first season, "Russian Roulette," led to the exoneration of two men who had been imprisoned for over two decades.
Credentials & credits
- Susan Simpson: Attorney (J.D., George Washington University Law School)
- Susan Simpson: Co-host of 'Undisclosed' podcast (2015-2021)
- Jacinda Davis: Executive Producer at Red Marble Media
- Jacinda Davis: B.A. in Psychology, University of Maryland
- Jacinda Davis: Two-time Emmy Award winner (Documentary Production)
Other ventures
- Susan Simpson: Undisclosed (podcast)
- Susan Simpson: The 45th (podcast)
- Jacinda Davis: Evil Lives Here (TV series)
- Jacinda Davis: Shattered (TV series)
- Jacinda Davis: Killer in Question (TV series)
What kind of podcast
- Country
- United States
- Region
- usa
When new episodes drop
- 01Proof Podcast: Season 3 "Murder at the Bikeshop." Sidebar 14May 4, 2026 · 17 min
- 02Sidebar 13 YoutubeApr 23, 2026 · 32 min
- 03Proof Podcast, Season 3: Murder at the Bikeshop. Sidebar 12.Apr 16, 2026 · 24 min
- 04Proof Podcast Season 3: Murder at the Bikeshop. Ep. 12 "Hush Hush"Apr 13, 2026 · 59 min
- 05Proof Podcast Season 3: Murder at the Bike Shop, Sidebar 11Apr 9, 2026 · 20 min
- 06Proof Podcast, Season 3: Murder at the Bike Shop. Ep. 11 "8,948 Days"Apr 6, 2026 · 49 min
Notable episodes
- 01Proof Podcast Season 3: Murder at the Bikeshop. Ep. 12 "Hush Hush"
In the season finale, the team uncovers documents suggesting a high-level conspiracy to suppress key witness testimony, with major implications for multiple cases.
- 02Sidebar 13 Youtube
Features a powerful interview with exoneree Lavon Hill, who knew the season's subject in prison and discusses the psychological toll of wrongful conviction.
- 03Proof Podcast: Season 3 "Murder at the Bikeshop." Sidebar 14
An interview with exoneree Eric Anderson, who now runs an organization to support others, highlighting the systemic lack of resources for the wrongfully convicted upon release.
What you'll be asked on this show
The show is co-hosted by Susan Simpson and Jacinda Davis, who guide listeners through complex legal cases with a serious, empathetic tone. Main episodes are tightly scripted narratives, while 'Sidebar' episodes are more conversational, often taking the form of an interview or a discussion between the hosts and their producer. The production is professional, with distinct musical cues for intros, outros, and transitions.
Questions Susan Simpson keeps coming back to
- “Can you share a little bit about your story and what happened to you?”
- “At what point did you realize the seriousness of your situation?”
- “Can you tell me about your connection to [case subject]?”
- “Where does this go from here?”
- “What was your take when you started getting into the cases and seeing the potential scale of it all?”
- “Do you find it's effective when you go to talk to lawmakers for them to actually meet exonerees and hear your stories?”
- “Do you ever in hindsight wish you had taken the plea deal?”
Signature segments
- · Season-long serialized investigations
- · "Sidebar" episodes for interviews and context
- · Interviews with exonerees
- · Uncovering new evidence during the investigation
- · Introductory and concluding music beds
Topics covered repeatedly
Who gets booked here
Guests are almost exclusively people with direct, firsthand experience in the criminal justice system. This includes exonerees who share their stories, attorneys from innocence projects, and other experts who can provide context on the cases being investigated.
- Eric Andersonon Proof Podcast: Season 3 "Murder at the Bikeshop." Sidebar 14
- Lavon Hillon Sidebar 13 Youtube
Where to find this show
Audience & reach
Estimated: The podcast is produced by Red Marble Media in association with Glassbox Media, indicating a professional production and sales structure. The audience is highly engaged, educated, and invested in justice-related issues. This would appeal to sponsors targeting a thoughtful demographic, including legal tech companies, educational services, and brands with a social responsibility focus.
Subscriber and view counts are pulled live from YouTube and re-verified on a 30-day cycle. Listener estimates for the RSS feed aren't published here unless they're host-verified.
Pitch Susan Simpson
p•••@•••.com+•• ••• ••• ••••Free: limited reveals · Pro: unlimited reveals + CSV export
You’re only charged when we return a verified hit.
People also ask
- Who are the hosts of Proof?
- The podcast is hosted by Susan Simpson, an attorney and co-host of the 'Undisclosed' podcast, and Jacinda Davis, an Emmy-winning TV producer for shows like 'Evil Lives Here'.
- What is the format of the podcast?
- Each season is a serialized, deep-dive investigation into a single case of potential wrongful conviction. These narrative episodes are supplemented by 'Sidebar' episodes featuring interviews and host discussions.
- Is the podcast still running?
- Yes, the podcast is actively releasing episodes, with the most recent evidence from early 2026.
- Where can I listen to Proof?
- The podcast is available on its official website, proofcrimepod.com, as well as on major podcast platforms like Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube.
- What are Susan Simpson's credentials?
- Susan Simpson is an attorney who graduated from George Washington University Law School. She previously co-hosted the wrongful conviction podcast 'Undisclosed' for six years.
- Has the podcast had any real-world impact?
- Yes, the investigation in the first season uncovered crucial evidence that led to the exoneration and release of Cain Joshua Storey and Darrell Lee Clark in Georgia.
Built from the show's public RSS feed, YouTube, the host's own websites, and the cited sources below. Computed and AI-extracted fields are labelled. Facts only — no private info, no fabrication, no transcripts republished.
Sources & how this page was built
This page is AI-assisted, grounded in the public sources cited below, and host-verifiable. We publish facts only; we do not republish transcripts. If anything here is wrong, the host can claim and correct the page above.Model: gemini-2.5-pro · high confidence
- [01]About - Proof Crime Podcastproofcrimepod.com
- [02]Susan Simpson - Bioproofcrimepod.com
- [03]Jacinda Davis - Bioproofcrimepod.com
- [04]About - Undisclosed Podcastundisclosed-podcast.com
- [05]About Me | The View From LL2 (Susan Simpson Blog)viewfromll2.com
- [06]Red Marble Media's Proof to premiere season two in 2023 - Podnewspodnews.net
- [07]About Red Marble Mediaredmarblemedia.com
Podcasts like Proof: A True Crime Podcast
Social Copyright By Shweta Jaya
Zee Media
A senior Indian journalist confronts controversial social, political, and religious topics through challenging, often confrontational, long-form interviews.
Talks From The Crypt
Brandon Lea
A visually-driven interview show where host Brandon Lea has long-form, casual conversations with creators in film, horror, and true crime.
Bedtime Stories
Written
A documentary-style horror anthology series detailing chilling cases of the paranormal, unsolved mysteries, and true crime.
STS True Crime Clips
STS True Crime
An Emmy-winning journalist analyzes trending true crime cases with law enforcement experts, journalists, and victims' families.
Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime
A former con man interviews criminals, law enforcement, and victims about the mechanics and psychology of non-violent crime.
True Crime Recaps
True Crime Recaps
A husband-and-wife duo delivers concise, fact-driven recaps of true crime cases, promising viewers 'all the crime in half the time'.
Shaun Attwood
Shaun Attwood
A former ecstasy kingpin turned author interviews ex-cons, cops, and conspiracy theorists about their life stories and hidden worlds.
The Conspiracy Files
A solo-narrated deep dive into disturbing true crime cases and conspiracy theories, focusing on child exploitation and alleged cover-ups.