Girls Rewatch Podcast
Hosted by Girls Rewatch
Two Brooklyn comedians and a guest revisit iconic 'girl shows' like Sex and the City, blending episode recaps with chaotic personal stories.
This is a TV rewatch podcast that uses shows like 'Sex and the City' as a launchpad for contemporary comedic conversations. The hosts and their comedian guests dissect episode plots through a modern, often critical, lens, but the real substance is the tangential, personal storytelling that the show's themes inspire. It functions as both a piece of pop culture analysis and a snapshot of the current Brooklyn alternative comedy scene.
“Unlike more straightforward recap shows, 'Girls Rewatch' is defined by its hosts' active careers in the Brooklyn comedy scene, which informs their perspective and guest list. The focus is less on reverent analysis and more on using the show as a comedic prompt for sharing personal stories and comparing generational views on love, work, and life in New York City.”
Who hosts this show
Girls Rewatch Podcast is hosted by Brooklyn-based comedians Amelia Ritthaler and Evan Lazarus. Each week, they are joined by a guest to revisit and recap episodes from iconic TV shows that shaped generations of women, including HBO's "Girls," Comedy Central's "Broad City," and currently, HBO's "Sex and the City". The show combines cultural analysis and a modern lens on dating, friendship, and careers with the hosts' and guests' own chaotic personal anecdotes. The podcast was named one of Vogue's "Best Podcasts of 2023".
Credentials & credits
- Brooklyn-based comedians
- Host of 'Girl Church' comedy show (Amelia Ritthaler)
- Host of 'Nancy' comedy show (Amelia Ritthaler)
- Co-host of 'Is This Gay?' comedy show (Evan Lazarus)
- Featured in New York Comedy Festival (Amelia Ritthaler)
- Writer
Other ventures
- Girl Church (monthly stand-up show)
- Nancy (biweekly stand-up show)
- Is This Gay? (monthly stand-up show)
What kind of podcast
- Country
- United States
- Region
- usa
When new episodes drop
- 01
- 02Recession Indicator: The Men Are Asking Me to PayJun 19, 2026 · 26s
- 03Pretending to Be a Lesbian to Climb Up the Corporate LadderJun 18, 2026 · 48s
- 04Marriage Shouldn't Be ForeverJun 17, 2026 · 36s
- 05
- 06Sex and the City S2E3: “The Freak Show” with Nick Smith | Girls Rewatch PodcastJun 9, 2026 · 1h 18m
- 07Sex and the City S2E2: “The Awful Truth” with Jamie Lee | Girls Rewatch PodcastJun 2, 2026 · 1h 06m
- 08
Notable episodes
- 01Sex and the City S2E2: “The Awful Truth” with Jamie Lee
Features well-known guest Jamie Lee (writer/producer on 'Ted Lasso', star of 'Crashing'), who discusses working with Judd Apatow and offers an insider's perspective on autofiction in television.
- 02Sex and the City S2E3: “The Freak Show” with Nick Smith
The guest, host of the 'I Never Liked You' podcast, brings a unique "hate-watch" perspective to the show, creating a dynamic and critical conversation about the characters.
- 03Sex and the City S2E5: “Four Women and a Funeral” with Carolina Montesquieu
A strong example of the show's standard format, where the comedian guest announces she is touring with 'Broad City' star Ilana Glazer, connecting the podcast's past and present subjects.
What you'll be asked on this show
The show is less a formal interview and more a structured, three-way conversation. It opens by establishing the guest's personal history with the TV show, asking questions like, "What's your journey with Sex and the City?" The hosts use plot points as springboards for direct, personal questions about the guest's own life, such as their dating history or opinions on social dilemmas presented in the episode. The discussion is built around recurring segments like "Girl, what girl are you?" and "What are you getting carried away with?" which integrate the guest into the show's established format. The style is collaborative and comedic, with all three participants riffing off each other's points rather than following a strict question-and-answer dynamic.
The show follows a two-host, one-guest format, characterized by a loose, highly collaborative, and comedic conversation. Episodes are structured with recurring signature segments that bookend the main episode discussion. The hosts frequently share personal anecdotes, often leading to long, chaotic tangents that are a core part of the show's appeal.
Questions Girls Rewatch keeps coming back to
10 cataloguedIf you're going on this show as a guest, expect some version of each of these. Each note explains when Girls Rewatch reaches for it.
origin
2- Q.01
“What's your relationship to [the show]?”
This is the standard opening question to establish the guest's personal history and level of fandom with the source material.
- Q.02
“Where are you from originally?”
Often asked early on to provide context for the guest's background and journey to New York.
personal
4- Q.01
“Girl, what girl are you?”
A signature segment where the guest must identify with one of the main characters from the show being discussed.
- Q.02
“What are you getting carried away with this week?”
A recurring segment where hosts and guest share a current personal obsession, thought, or anecdote.
- Q.03
“Have you ever had an experience like [plot point from the episode]?”
Connects a specific, often awkward or funny, situation from the show to the guest's own life.
- Q.04
“What's your relationship to [topic from the episode]?”
Probes the guest's personal feelings or experiences with a theme from the episode, such as dirty talk or dating apps.
future
1- Q.01
“Where can the girls find you?”
The standard closing question, allowing the guest to promote their social media, shows, or other projects.
values
1- Q.01
“What's your take on [dilemma from the episode]?”
This question uses a moral or social issue from the plot to prompt a personal opinion from the guest.
process
1- Q.01
“When was your most recent rewatch of the show?”
This question gauges how fresh the material is for the guest and their viewing habits.
relationships
1- Q.01
“Are you in love or married?”
A very direct question asked to connect the show's relationship themes to the guest's current status.
Signature segments
- · Girl, what girl are you?
- · Getting Carried Away
- · Welcome back to Girls Rewatch, a podcast about Girls, TV, and girls on TV.
Topics covered repeatedly
Who gets booked here
Guests are typically fellow comedians, writers, and actors, many of whom are active in the New York comedy scene. They are expected to have a personal connection to the show being discussed and a willingness to share openly about their own lives and opinions.
- Carolina Montesquieuon Sex and the City S2E5: “Four Women and a Funeral” with Carolina Montesquieu | Girls Rewatch Podcast
- Saidahon Sex and the City S2E4: “They Shoot Single People, Don’t They?” with Saidah | Girls Rewatch Podcast
- Nick Smithon Sex and the City S2E3: “The Freak Show” with Nick Smith | Girls Rewatch Podcast
- Jamie Leeon Sex and the City S2E2: “The Awful Truth” with Jamie Lee | Girls Rewatch Podcast
- Marty Miller and Missy McIntoshon Sex and the City S2E1: “Take Me Out to the Ball Game” with Marty Miller and Missy McIntosh
Where to find this show
Audience & reach
Based on observed sponsorships (e.g., Nuuly, Jones Road Beauty, Square), the podcast appears to attract direct-to-consumer brands targeting a millennial and Gen Z female audience interested in lifestyle, fashion, and wellness. The hosts also heavily promote their own Substack subscription for ad-free content.
Subscriber and view counts are pulled live from YouTube and re-verified on a 30-day cycle. Listener estimates for the RSS feed aren't published here unless they're host-verified.
Pitch Girls Rewatch
People also ask
- Who are the hosts of Girls Rewatch Podcast?
- The hosts are Brooklyn-based comedians Amelia Ritthaler and Evan Lazarus.
- What is the format of the show?
- Each week, the two hosts and a guest comedian recap and discuss an episode of a popular TV show, blending cultural analysis with personal stories and humor.
- What TV shows has the podcast covered?
- They have covered HBO's 'Girls' and Comedy Central's 'Broad City,' and are currently rewatching HBO's 'Sex and the City'.
- Is the podcast still active?
- Yes, new episodes are released every Tuesday.
- How can I listen to ad-free episodes?
- Ad-free episodes and other exclusive content are available by subscribing to the Girls Rewatch Podcast on Substack.
- Where can I listen to the podcast?
- The podcast is available on major platforms like Apple Podcasts and Spotify, with full video episodes on their YouTube channel.
Built from the show's public RSS feed, YouTube, the host's own websites, and the cited sources below. Computed and AI-extracted fields are labelled. Facts only — no private info, no fabrication, no transcripts republished.
Sources & how this page was built
This page is AI-assisted, grounded in the public sources cited below, and host-verifiable. We publish facts only; we do not republish transcripts. If anything here is wrong, the host can claim and correct the page above.Model: gemini-2.5-pro · high confidence
- [01]Girls Rewatch Podcast - YouTube Channelyoutube.com
- [02]Girls Rewatch Podcast | Substackgirlsrewatch.substack.com
- [03]Amelia Ritthaler's Official Websiteameliaritthaler.com
- [04]Girls Rewatch on Apple Podcastspodcasts.apple.com
- [05]Brooklyn-based comedy duo Amelia Ritthaler and Evan Lazarus tackle comedy...nyunews.com
- [06]Evan Lazarus joins Shelfshelfmag.com
- [07]Girls Rewatch - Emerald Audioemeraldaudio.net
Podcasts like Girls Rewatch Podcast
Saad Rashid - YouTube Automation
Saad Rashid
A Pakistani host interviews creators of 'faceless' YouTube channels, breaking down their niche strategies, AI workflows, and revenue generation.
The History Guy: History Deserves to Be Remembered
A history storyteller who narrates short, engaging videos about forgotten events and figures, typically in 15 minutes or less.
Middle Nation
Middle Nation
A political commentator analyzes global events from a pro-Muslim, anti-imperialist perspective, advocating for decolonization and sovereignty.
The Founder's Dream | Abhishek vyas
The Founder
A Hindi-language business podcast featuring long-form interviews with Indian startup founders about their real-world journeys and industries.
Donovan Sharpe
Donovan Sharpe
A confrontational live-stream show focused on dating, masculinity, and current events from a "Red Pill" perspective.
HAHA Podcast
Three Korean-American sisters and YouTubers bring their chaotic, unfiltered group chat to a weekly video podcast.
We In Miami Podcast
A Miami-based interview show where host Stunt Lifestyle gets hip-hop and reality TV stars to talk about their careers, feuds, and personal lives.
Voice of Mogasala | Telugu Podcast
Siva Kalyan
A serious Telugu podcast where host Siva Kalyan Mogasala interviews medical and professional experts to explain and debunk myths about pressing health and societal issues.